Our elected officials should be accountable to the public. Law enforcement officers should be accountable to the public. These are undeniably true. But most of us don’t use that sentiment to defend walking into local government offices with a camera and trying to film employees’ computer screens, or bothering people outside a post office. Welcome to the world of “First Amendment auditors,” a community of . . . well, let’s call them “enthusiastic enforcers of their own conception of what’s allowable on public property.” Get ready for your closeup!
The auditors’ devotion to the U.S. Constitution and suspicion of authority might read to observers as libertarian-coded, but the YouTubers I spoke with claim not to have any partisan motivations. Rather, they’re asserting their right to record as a contrived stress test of whether public officials respect that right. Auditors’ MOs run the gamut. Some clearly seem to be goading police officers, government workers, and passersby into engaging with them. Others take a more stoic tack, refusing to answer questions or saying as little as possible. Still others identify as citizen journalists. Sometimes the audits are a laid-back affair, but the ones that rack up the most views are those where people captured in the video lose it, making themselves unwitting stars of a pseudo–soap opera.
More picks from Slate
Inside America’s Shoplifting Lab
“In the war on ‘shrink,’ big retailers are turning to one Florida outfit to study shoppers and prevent them from stealing. I went there—and saw far too much.”
The Forgotten Bombing of LaGuardia Airport
“It’s been called ‘one of the greatest cold cases of the 20th century.’ It remains unsolved. But what happened next is almost a worse crime.”
The Florida Alligator Dragnet
“When an alligator kills someone in America, it can make international headlines. What happens to the thousands of gators that people deem ‘nuisances’ does not.”
How the Crossword Conquered America
“Even in a boom time for games, the decidedly old-fashioned puzzles are more popular than ever. I went to the best place on Earth to understand why.”
The Capybaras Aren’t All Right
“The internet’s favorite animal is facing a dark fate.”
The Strange Saga of Faces of Death
“It scarred countless children—and allegedly left one dead. Many still believe it was all real. Some of it was.”
