In the Orion winter 2025/2026 issue dedicated to cryptids, Katherine Cusumano dives into the mythology of New York City’s Gowanus Canal, one of the most toxic waterways in the US. The canal is a Superfund site of mutant monsters, sentient slime, and poisonous sludge, and yet Cusumano reimagines it as a place of possibility and transformation.

In one way, the story of the three-eyed catfish possessed a strange optimism, evidence of our desire for the natural world to persist in spite of the human capacity for environmental destruction. Whether or not the fish was real wasn’t even the point. The point was the wanting to believe in the canal as a place of possibility—a story New York is famous for telling about itself, though perhaps not normally about its toxic waste sites. If animal bodies could transmute, then there might be a chance for all of us to be made new.

More picks from Orion

Feeding the Revolution

Victoria Blanco | Orion | October 5, 2026 | 3,659 words

“The burrito’s history as a symbol of resistance.”

Tomato Cure

Seth Kaplan | Orion Magazine | September 16, 2026 | 1,700 words

“The quiet medicine of small jobs, finished before dark.”

Why Are Fish So Gay?

Lars Horn, Sabrina Imbler, Lulu Miller, and Joseph Osmundson | Orion | May 27, 2026 | 4,189 words

“A conversation about finding community in the aquatic.”

Lord God Bird

J. Drew Lanham | Orion | December 29, 2025 | 4,721 words

“Does the ivory-billed woodpecker still exist?”

Cheri has been an editor at Longreads since 2014.