Jimi Hendrix’s music has found timeless purchase not just as transcendent music, but transcendent protest music. To wit: his searing rendition of the national anthem at Woodstock, not to mention the epochal mindblower “Purple Haze.” For The American Scholar, James McManus deconstructs both tunes, as well as the circumstances that made Hendrix such a singular genius. While there’s no peg to speak of, it’s still perfect timing. After all, lately things don’t seem the same.

We’ve all heard plenty of renditions of “The Star-Spangled Banner”—by marching bands, pianists, string quartets, altos and tenors and baritones, perhaps the odd basso profundo. We’ve watched Whitney Houston lip-syncing it at Tampa Stadium as flags waved and fighters screamed overhead. We’ve seen tenor Jim Cornelison of the Lyric Opera of Chicago rousing veterans and other Blackhawks fans night after night at the United Center, and a blue-haired Jack White playing just the melody on his vintage Kay Archtop acoustic (the “Seven Nation Army” guitar, speaking of ubiquitous licks) at Comerica Park on Opening Day. We’ve booed Roseanne Barr’s off-key screeching at Jack Murphy Stadium and howled at Maya Rudolph’s mordant rendition on SNL. Linda Ronstadt sang it prettily enough at Chavez Ravine before Game 3 of the ’77 World Series. Wynton Marsalis went a little flat in the Superdome, Mariah Carey forgot the words but still ripped sweetly through four or five octaves in the Madhouse on Madison, Marvin Gaye epically toned it up in The Forum … but nothing remotely like Hendrix at Woodstock.

More picks about rock music

The Portal Opens

Amanda Petrusich | The New Yorker | April 14, 2025 | 9,925 words

“People who love Phish do so with a quasi-religious devotion. People who dislike Phish do so with an equal fervor.”

The Dave Matthews Guide to Living and Dying

Alex Pappademas | GQ | May 18, 2023 | 5,777 words

“Now 56, Matthews has been singing about mortality for a long time, and he’s confronting its specter in new and surprising ways.”

Inside Superiority Burger

Brett Martin | GQ | April 26, 2023 | 3,834 words

“How did chef and former punk drummer Brooks Headley turn his all-vegetarian vision for a rock and roll diner into the season’s hottest new restaurant?”