Marian Fraser once ran Spoiled Rotten, the go-to day care for Waco’s elite. But people turned against her after she was arrested for the death of a child in her charge. The cause: Benadryl poisoning. Parents came to believe Fraser had been deliberately drugging children. But the truth, Michael Hardy finds, might be less nefarious:

During more than three dozen interviews and over multiple trips to Waco, I kept hearing versions of one refrain: Something about the story didn’t add up. How could a woman who loved children as much as Fraser did be in prison for murdering a four-month-old baby? “There is a missing piece somewhere,” insisted Michelle Franks, who sent her daughter Rachel to Spoiled Rotten in the mid-nineties. “Marian could never do something like that intentionally and live with herself.”

As it turned out, there was a missing piece, a key detail that had been withheld from the police, the prosecutors, and the public for the past twelve years. The new information helped fill in the puzzle. But it also challenged everything I thought I knew about the case.

More picks about true crime

The Shooting of Two Cornell Freshmen, 42 Years Later

Dylan Alphenaar | Collegetown Magazine | March 2, 2026 | 6,010 words

“In 1983 six students were taken hostage in a Cornell dormitory. Two of them were killed. How have the survivors reckoned with what happened to them, and what made us forget about this act of violence?”

The Man Who Broke Into Jail

James Verini | The New Yorker | March 2, 2026 | 13,480 words

“In Nashville, a criminal-justice activist commits a baffling crime.”