What do Hollywood writers really think of generative AI? In interviews with screenwriters and filmmakers, Josh Rottenberg reveals a sharp divide—some view AI as a gimmick, others hail it as a revolutionary force. To one, ChatGPT could even be the next Spielberg. As the industry barrels toward an AI-assisted future, it finds itself caught between the promise of innovation and the need to protect the human soul of storytelling.
Some studio executives may already be imagining a future with fewer writers, a field that’s historically one of the most developmentally expensive and unpredictable parts of making a movie. Since the spec script boom of the 1990s, when writers like Shane Black (“Lethal Weapon”) commanded multimillion-dollar paydays, screenwriting has carried a uniquely speculative price structure for work that’s often unproven. Robert Altman’s 1992 film “The Player” famously centered on a murder of a screenwriter, satirizing the industry’s long love-hate relationship with the written word.
But Gupta pushes back on that vision. He says AI is far from being able to write a good movie on its own — at least not yet. “You could watch it,” he says. “But you’re not going to like watching it.” What excites him more is the potential for co-creation, humans still driving the process with machines supporting rather than replacing them.
More picks on AI
The People of Utah vs. Kevin O’Leary
“Mr. Wonderful wanted to build the world’s largest data center. The neighbors had other ideas.”
How AI Replaced Me
“An edtech worker’s account of what got left behind.”
Paid Phones
“Owing the payday loan apps.”
Why Is Everyone In Tech So Sad?
“A lot of people seem to be realizing that knowledge work is mostly pointless. AI might give us the pleasure of finding out what happens if an entire class of workers loses faith in their careers.”
Welcome to the Age of AI Crime and Punishment
“America’s legal system is already grappling with cases where chatbots acted as lawyers and witnesses, generated the evidence, or helped plan a mass shooting. Who will be liable now that some AI agents are doing crimes all on their own?”
What Happens When a Kid’s Robot Best Friend Dies?
“AI companion toys for neurodivergent children promise connection and therapy, but can they deliver for the long haul?”
